Book Review: Dog Sense by Sneed B. Collard III


Being a teen or pre-teen is hard enough without throwing into the mix moving to an entirely new and boring  city, coping with having  lost a father due to his having  deserted his family, being bullied at school, having superior math skills but finding English to be a challenge,  summoning the courage to speak to a girl that you have a crush on and various other challenges that life has put in your path.

From the Publisher:

Montana is a long way from California. Thirteen-year-old Guy is trying to make the best of a difficult situation. He and his mother have moved in with his grandfather after his father’s “unannounced departure.” Back home, Guy skateboarded, surfed, and played video games with his friends. Here the kids only seem to talk about cars, fishing, and hunting.

Life at Big Sky Middle School is also a disappointment. Guy is bored in math class and over his head in English. He quickly becomes a target for Brad Mullen, class bully. But at least Guy has his beloved Border collie, Streak, and eventually he makes a friend, classmate Luke Grant. Soon Guy and Luke hatch a plan to train Streak to compete against Brad Mullen and his dog at the town’s Frisbee catching competition. But the rivalry between Guy and Brad escalates until an impulsive wager pits the boys head to head and places Streak in jeopardy.

Veteran author Sneed Collard offers young readers an affecting, realistic portrait of an adolescent boy who must learn to cope with conflicts and challenges in an unfamiliar environment and to accept changes in his life that are beyond his control.

I don’t know if it is because I am a woman, but when I finished this book  (and finding that it did not hold my interest well I found it took me longer to finish reading Dog Sense than most of the books that I review),I felt rather ho-hum.

I did like the author’s direct and conversational style, but I believe I would have enjoyed this book more had there been more of a reference to DOGS. For me, the title Dog Sense led me to believe the dogs in the book would play a larger role. I felt their appearance in the book was rather weak. I would have enjoyed reading less about the bullying of Guy by Brad, and would have enjoyed reading MORE about the impact their respective dogs had on their life.

This book didn’t tug at my heart, grab my attention or make me think, and to me those are all requisites of a “good read.”

Dog Sense will appeal to boys ages 8-12, beyond that?  It is doubtful.  Will  girls relate to Dog Sense?  Also doubtful. As a pre-teen and teen my family moved quite a bit and my family was also broken. Did having lived those experiences allow Dog Sense to touch a place deep within me? No.

Would I have liked much more of a story that put more emphasis on the DOGS of Dog Sense? Absolutely.

Put on your “must read” list?  If you are a boy ages 8-12 maybe,  anyone else? A resounding. NO.

  • Hardcover: $14.95
  • ISBN: 978-1-56145-351-1
Advertisements

The URI to TrackBack this entry is: https://dakotasden.wordpress.com/2012/04/30/book-review-dog-sense-by-sneed-b-collard-iii/trackback/

RSS feed for comments on this post.

12 CommentsLeave a comment

  1. What a bummer 😦 The premise sounds great, but some books simply don’t flow.

    • Hi Sara! Now remember, it could just be me. I thought that since the dogs were supposed to have been an important part of this book that developing their personalities was important. It all fell flat with me but it could just be me!

      Barks and licks and love from Dakota and “Mom”

  2. Thanks for the review, Auntie Caren! So Mom knows which books to read for me!

    Licks
    Eva

    • Eva you are most welcome!! We are glad that you enjoyed this! Barks and licks and all of my love, Dakota

  3. Great honest review! The title alone leads you to believe this book is mostly about dogs. I’m with you on what constitutes a “good read”!

    • Thank you Bassetmomma, in my opinion there just wasn’t enough time spent on the DOGS! But…that being said….it could just be me!

  4. I was totally expecting this to be all about Dogs too – good review by your Mum Dakota 🙂

    I hope you’re having a fun day,

    Your pal Snoopy 🙂

    • Hi Snoopy! It IS about dogs but not to the extent that Mom expected….for Mom it just fell flat!

      Hope you are having a fun day too!

      Barks and licks and love, Dakota

  5. I wonder of Sneed B. Collard III will name his son Sneed B. Collard IV so he can be bullied too…and write a book about it…
    Kisses
    Nellie
    (tongue in cheek, not being snarky)

    • Nellie….PRICELESS!!! Barks and licks and love, Dakota hehehe

  6. Reblogged this on Laggylife's Blog.

    • laggylife it might be nice if you asked for permission to do that first. I notice 2 of my posts and a few of Rumpy Dog’s there…you certainly should ask permission first.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: